Article

← Retour au blog

🇫🇷 Lire en français

App Store: 100k apps, what's next? Consolidation!

2009-11-14 #964 · rév. 1 · EN

While reaching 100k applications is undeniably a sign of developer enthusiasm for Apple’s mobile platform, it deserves to be nuanced, or at least analyzed a bit more closely.

What attracts developers, beyond the iPhone itself, is the new business model offered by Apple: in exchange for 25% of the gross revenue generated by the application, Apple handles distribution, payment processing, and customer management. This is a far cry from traditional retail distribution, where the developer only collects 10 to 15% of the retail price. Furthermore, the direct market access offered by Apple also seems to reinject freedom into the creative process, and developers no longer have to endure the endless demands of publishers.

To me, it is clear that the App Store is fully benefiting from a windfall effect: developers — whether individuals or small businesses — think they are going to hit the jackpot.

Yet nothing could be further from the truth. It turns out that only the top 100 applications generate significant revenue; the rest generate almost no income. Worse still, a huge number of applications are simply never downloaded at all!

In fact, let’s do a simple calculation together: the App Store has achieved 2 billion downloads in its 16 months of existence. Divided among 100 thousand applications, that is an average of only 20 thousand downloads per application!
This leads us to the following: if 100% of applications were paid — say €0.79 — each application would only generate €7,400 excl. tax in gross annual revenue for the developer — after deducting Apple’s share and VAT.
We can clearly see that this success is not quite what it seems when reading the raw numbers.

Moreover, the calculation above is far from the truth for the vast majority of application authors simply because their apps are offered for free.
One might wonder why. Indeed, building an application, even a basic one, represents a significant production effort involving many hours of work. Do developers place no value on their work? Or is it merely a stylistic exercise for them?

Many developers are indeed simple hobbyists with no commercial approach. As for the others, many are riding the iPhone buzz and carrying out development contracts for third parties — much like web agencies do. The value of these contracts is relatively low, around €15k.
As for small video game development studios, they produce games for budgets ranging between €50k and €100k.

So why do applications see so little commercial success? Well, I believe authors have somewhat forgotten a fundamental ingredient required for a product to achieve economic success: marketing.

Indeed, how can a user know that the application of their dreams exists among the 100,000 available on the App Store? It is literally like looking for a needle in a haystack. It is simply impossible without an advertising campaign, impossible without the media, impossible without a marketing budget!
Here again, despite Apple’s efforts, no solution other than a marketing campaign will let the public know that this incredible application is made for them.

As we can clearly see, the App Store ultimately remains a traditional market where making a living is not so different from anywhere else. And once developers understand this, we will witness a severe consolidation. The number of applications will grow more slowly, but quality will increase. The race to the bottom on pricing will come to an end.

This overview of the App Store ecosystem would not be complete without mentioning one last pitfall: the application review process. It is Apple’s way of maintaining a certain degree of quality, or simply preventing a new application from cannibalizing the features of another.
Access to the App Store is therefore subject to Apple’s approval; and given the volume of submissions, wait times are quite long — with a minimum of 2 weeks; and above all, the outcome is hard to predict, even when strictly following the guidelines published by Apple.

So, between low financial returns and the risk of rejection — or the uncertainty of approval times —
we are starting to read statements from certain developers announcing their withdrawal from the platform.

Has market consolidation already begun?